Subscribe to TV Guide Magazine
TV Guide Magazine - The Official Magazine of Television™
Home
News
Columns
Photos
Videos
Shows
Subscribe
Polls
Home > Ask Matt > Ask Matt Returns!
Ask Matt
Ask Matt Returns!
Miranda Penn Turin/FOX

Ask Matt Returns!
March 05, 2009 12:00 AM EST

Welcome back, loyal and patient readers! The hiatus is over, and Ask Matt is back to discuss, debate and answer your burning questions (with a minimum of spoilers) about TV: the shows, the scheduling, the ups and downs and twists and turns that keep us coming back (or sometimes not) each and every week. Note that there’s a new address to send questions (askmatt@tvguidemagazine.com), and I look forward to hearing from you again. In the meanwhile, here’s a sampling of some of the mail that’s been stacking up during our transition.

Question: What’s your take on the recent reports that Universal is working up a movie version of Battlestar Galactica that has as little relation to the current series as Sci Fi’s masterpiece has to the cheesy original show? I don’t see the point. —Sarah L

Matt Roush: Frankly, neither do I. Not being one to prejudge, though I’m more than a little skeptical that this will actually come to pass, I find it puzzling that the impulse here seems to be to return the franchise closer to its original state, with series creator Glen Larson again at the helm. Which seems to me comparable to returning the Batman franchise to the kiddie-show tone of the ’60s series (which I loved in its kooky way) after the triumph of The Dark Knight (which, putting it mildly, is much more successful than any incarnation of Battlestar will ever be). Many of us regard the reinvention of Battlestar Galactica into a rich, relevant, emotionally compelling and disturbing meditation on humanity as something of a miracle. Turning the show back into a replica of its former, lesser self just looks like the most misguided form of crass commercialism.

Question: I hadn't realized how much I appreciated your Internet columns until they weren't there. And I really hate not having had much insight into your opinions of Dollhouse as it begins. I see the beginning as a pretty good start, but definitely just a start. Here's hoping the ratings improve for both it and Terminator, but those sleazy promos have to go. Ugh. —Anna

Matt Roush: I missed you all, too, more than you’ll know. And isn’t Dollhouse an odd creature of a show? I’m intrigued by it, if not convinced yet that this show will end up in the Joss pantheon of classics. But the three episodes I screened before the premiere (1, 2 and 4) got progressively better, which is a hopeful sign, ratings aside. And during several public appearances I attended with Joss Whedon in New York before the premiere (moderating a panel at the New York Comic-Con and, a few nights later, a gathering at the Apple store in Soho), he promised that the sixth episode, airing March 20 (the same night as, sniff, Battlestar Galactica’s finale), is a real game-changer. That’s the episode when Echo and Agent Ballard finally cross paths. As is usually the case when a show this offbeat is in its infancy, I’m hoping it will find its way and get the time to prove itself. The numbers on Friday, as expected, have been pretty pitiful, but that was to be expected. As for those “sleazy” promos: I though they were kind of fun in the way they evoked ’70s “grindhouse” sexploitation. Of course, anyone who knows anything about the Terminator series, and Dollhouse for that matter, knows these promos didn’t reflect their true spirit. Still, can’t blame Fox for trying. Now we just have to trust that the network will leave both shows alone until the end of the season before making a decision about their (iffy) future.
Next Next  (page 1 of 4)
Bookmark and Share
Post your own comment:
Name:
Email address:
Comment (500 characters left)
Security code: [Generate another]
All fields are required. Your email address will not be published.
Refresh / Reload the page to see your comments.
 
Photo Galleries
Today's Hot Topic Who should win the Oscar for Best Director?
Who should win the Oscar for Best Director?







Click here to vote and see more polls!
More Polls
 
About Us Subscribe Advertising Customer Service Contact Us Privacy Policy Join Our Reader Panel RSS Site Map
Copyright © 2009 TV Guide Magazine. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.